Democracy is the rule of the majority, by the majority and for the majority. And that may be considered as the biggest loophole of democracy. And,moreover having this rule working in sync with the judgment is more vital.
The so-called secularist, optimist and my atheist friends says that India has changed a lot. Obviously, India has changed a lot in the past 60 years unless/if my memory supports the basic facts.
1. First, in 1947, when we witnessed the partition of our country and the death of Mahatma Gandhi by Nathu Ram Godse.
2. Operation Blue Star ,where we saw the widespread anti-Sikh riots.
3. During the Mandal-Kamandal politics of 90’s and the rise of most fundamentalist party of India - the BJP as the strongest opposition.
4. Lastly, during the period of IT rise under the pretext of globalization and liberalization, we have seen Godhra and that also in the most prosperous state - Gujarat.
And, we show off that “we” Indian people have become matured enough? Let’s hope no more Godhras in the land of Ram, Allah, Guru Nanak, Christ etc.
Not, from the pessimist point of view, but, I know, these things are going to happen in India again and again, where still 60% people are below the poverty line, and elections are the only basic means when they can get proper food for the stipulated time period. Taking the name of Ram, Allah at night or just by drinking water can only pacify their hunger when their stomach demands for it?
Aren’t we expecting more from them? Expectations are followed by demand and which is not our legal right. During the last 50 years, it has been seen here that Indian majority and their faith and belief always goes with the Ram Lalla. Their faith and belief can be best seen during the ongoing Durga Mahotsava. It is the faith and belief only which has attracted millions of Muslims brothers to the Mecca and lakhs of Hindu pilgrims to the Kailash Mansarovar. It is the faith and belief only which has changed the name of Bombay into Mumbai, Madras into Chennai, and Calcutta into Kolkata. If a single judgment can pacify the hearts of 80% Indian population, then let the faith and belief be restored.
What about the questions of historians? Does it validate? They have written many things and given many findings about Gandhiji? It is the faith and belief only which has made him Mahatma for the older people and ”Bapu” in the eyes of kids. 'Let faith and belief be restored'.
Moreover, how many corrections are we going to do? The Constitution of India shows the map of India in the most potential way by just hiding the basic facts from its Indian Nationals. What about the Aksai Chin (part under the Chinese control) and the Pakistan occupied Kashmir (POK).The Indian constitution doesn’t allow the foreign nationals without a valid passport. What about the migrant Bangladeshis in W. Bengal? There are many facts which have been suppressed. Indian Constitution is not only made to provide the truth, but to run the country in a peaceful and consistent manner. Statistics and examples are really confusing in determining the minds of people.
BJP has swept all the seven Municipal Corporation seats. This cannot be linked directly to the Godhra case as the same BJP has lost in UP-Assembly Election three years back from where the fire of Ayodhya erupted?
We are blaming only politics and the political people? What our conscience doing? The sentiments of the Indian educated class is very much dynamic. They are not bothered about the Afzal Guru case, and for why? Simply because it’s directly associated with the sentiments of the Kashmir valley. What about the adivasis of Chhattisgarh, and the Christian minority in Orrisa? What about the facts and evidence? And what about the faith and belief? Facts and evidence are succumbing to faith and belief for the betterment of society.
India has not yet matured enough. What can we expect better from the Indian population? She is not yet prepared for the ”VASUDHAIVA KUTUMBAKAM”.
(This article is purely the writer’s viewpoint. It is written NOT against any particular community but in the interest of the larger sections of the INDIAN Society.)
Raj Mohan The assasination of MG was not correct. But at that time the way MG behaved any patriot Indian would have got offended. MD Ali Jinnah was suffering from cancer at the time of partition his wish was to achieve PM's post but because MG was under the influence of PT.Nehru he was forced to allow PT.Nehru as PM of this country and the partition became inevitable.
ReplyDeleteRegarding Operation Blue Star I must say that India Gandhi oops Indira should have handled this situation in a much better way. And the sikh riots was inevitable as the then Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi gave a very politcally immature and provoking statement after the assaination of his mother “JAB KOI BADA PED GIRTA HAI TAB DHARTI TO HILTI HI HAI”
Such provoking statements are not expected from a Prime Minister. A Prime Minister should act like a statesman. Take the eaxmple of Mr.Vajpayee during he gave statement during Guj Riots to the CM of Gujarat to follow Raj Dharma.That is a symbol of a statesman.
I don't know how and on what basis you call BJP a fundmentalist party? Can you please elaborate? If the BJP is a fundamentalist party why can't the Congress or other so called liberal Parties get it delisted from Election Commission. Don't give your judgements just for the sake of it.
You are trying to say that POK or the Aksai Chin is not with us still we live in an illusion about them being with us. Let me tell you POK is our territory. and if it is not with us it is just because of the failure of a party which has ruled for most of the period since independence. And you conveniently skipped the point about China calling Arunachal as their terriory which is still under our control? It is simply ridiculous when they mock our so called 'Great Prime Minister's' visit to Arunachal and the Prime Miniter and his partymen maintain a mysterious silence. You talked about illegal migration of B'Deshis in WB but again you conveniently skipped the same thing which happened in Assam because of an anti national and unconstitutional act passed by the so called secularist parties. Thanks to the honourable Supreme Court that they scrapped it.
I simply can't understand how are you linking BJP's success or failure in elections with Godhra or GUJ Riots? Who says Indians are not botherred about the exeution of Afzal Guru or Kasab. But what one can do if the CM of a state had been been asked by the Union Home Minister to keep the file of Afzal Guru as Pending. Regarding Naxalism I must say that current ruling party is very much divided in dealing with Naxalism as we have seen the the 'Noora Kushti' between the Home Minister of our country and general secretary of his own party. Violence in Orissa happened because of conversion done by Christian Missionaries by using wrong methods which can provoke the sentiments of any community.
If India was not mature then we wouldn't have witnessed which we are seeing now after the Ayodhya verdict
Well Raj I don’t agree with you at certain points..
ReplyDeleteSee, definitely India has progressed a lot and the recent Ajodhya judgement and people's reaction is self-evident. The whole country was on high alert but as far as I am concern not even a single yard faced trouble on communal basis after the verdict. The mind set of people is changing. now even they know fighting for religion will give them blood not bread...India's socio economic condition back in 1991 was pathetic...and after 20 years hell lot of changes has taken place because of globalisation....now even d middle class Indian is dreaming to become a global Indian and he know he can do it, education facility has improved...I know, still there is lot more 2 cover but when we compare todays situation with that of 1991 when riots had taken place then certainly we can say that we have moved far ahead.
and as far as religion and politics is concerned then I must say dat the world has been governed in the name of god since time in memorials be it the crusade war in Europe, killing of Jews during 2nd world war or riots in 1991.even the whole western world politics has been greatly influenced by roman catholic church and even today the war against Muslims in US is burning example of this. And this is simply because of the simple human philosophy, people easily come out to fight in d name of unknown, unseen god but their foot reluctantly moves in order to protect their own rights or any other fellow human in danger, they donate money to religious organisation but hardy feed any poor hungry child. we need to change this mind set. Neither I am atheist nor I am trying to make u guys atheist, what point I am trying 2 make here is, believe in supreme religion of humanity which is the gist of teaching of every religion. This can only be done by educating people.
on aksai chin and pok,as rightly pointed out by aman, india does nt accept dat map and china and pak is having control over dat bcoz of d failure of negotiatns btw d countries and para 6 of simla agreement of 1972 clearly says that current boundries are not final and is subject 2 negotiations btw d concerned countries.even para 4 clause (ii) clearly distinguishes current boundries from international boundries and terms it as line of conflict.so its disputted matter.recently FAO has released a map showing both parts as parts of Pak and china over which Indian govt had shown deep concern.
Ur termin BJP as fundamentalist party bcoj riots took place in godhara durin its tenure,den I would like to put som light upon d riots dat took place in 1948 & 1984 and d reson behind partition of India.
ReplyDeleted whole world knws dat d partition btw india and pak was avoidable and nehru was as much responsible as Jinnah was. If u could remember jinnah was initially in congress and was patriot of hindu muslim unity,bt it was prominent congress leader of dat tym who breached his trust and forced him 2 believe dat congress was more of a hindu party and muslims will gain nothin frm it and thus it was for d betterment of his community 2 create his own self managed country which would hav done by any resasonable person with normal prudence in his place.
its really shockin for our countrymen dat the history dat is being taught in our schools is nt wat had happened bt wat congress showed had happened. It’s entirely twisted and away from ground realities. I simply can’t understand how twin sons India nd pak born out of same d mother can hav different birth history. works and contibution of congress leaders has been exaggerated jus 2 make it sure dat the whole india thru generatns can bow low under dis burden n accept their invisible monarchy which was clealy reflected by Indira Gandhi's policy in 1977.Prima faci it may look weired 2 som people dats d ugly truth
world knws dis dat india gain freedom bcoz Britishers were incapable of handalin India or better 2 say its all collonies aftr world war 2
and dats y many asian countries like India,malasia,dutch east indies,and othr south asian and african countries btw 1945 to 1960.
So if we look deeper into d facts den probly d credit for India's freedom(and rest of d countries) goes to a man born in
Europe(nt 2 gandhi or nehru
),whose overambitious nature led to world war 2
(yaa I knw I knw u gussed it rite, he was Hitler)and d man who discoverd atom bom whose blast acted as clarion for ending Imperialism.
To my respected frnz Aman.
ReplyDelete1)the assassination of Mahatma was totally incorrect.offended by anybody dont give us the power to kill.if a child is offended by his parents,he cant kill them.Moreover,he wasnt under te influence of Nehruji only, bt,for the sake of 80%Indian Hindus.Any statement of Nathu Ram Godse wont make him right.He wanted to treat both India and Pakistan as his offsprings.particularly more to Pakistan like a mother."ek Maa apne langre bacche ka khayal hamesha zyada rakhti hai."I dont think 80% Indian Hindus were really ready to be governed under MINORITY rule(JInnah particularly).
2)There is no question of "operation Blue Star."my point has to be only seen as an xample of roits and the maturity of Indian people.
3)Regarding the statement of Mr.Bajpayee to Gujarat C.M,which i hv not a very good knowledge:-But I know only 1 thing.the riots has took place for 2 continuous months.and the time isnt less enough for any C.M to stop it???
4)If "Babri Demolition" isnt enough to make BJP the fundamentalist party,then its the only party having "HINDUTVA"ideology on the lines of "JEHAD" followed by Islamic militants.The party having the connection with RSS and VHP.
5)for China Aksai Chin or Arunachal Pradesh,you can refer the map released by China's Government 2 days ago.
6)POK-there no question of success or failure of any party.my post is only about running the country peacefully,bt not for the sake of correctness.
7)there is a line in my post which reads-"Statistics and examples are really confusing in determining the minds of people."the correlation of gujarat riots-elections in gujarat and U.P is just serving the purpose of my statement.
8)India has really become matured now coz te judgement is in favour of 80%Indians.Democracy just work on the principle of "Food Pyramid."one majority class is just reaping the benefits of minority class under it.
@Raj Mohan Its not the matter of Nathu Ram Godse being right or wrong. I just mean to say that many times one has to take decisions as per the requirements of the situation. And for god's sake please don't all Pakistan langda baccha. You know how that so called 'langda baccha' is treating us post independene. hwo can you assume that Hindus were not ready to be governed by Jinnah. PT, Nehru was having serious lust to grab the PM's post so he made sure that JInnah isn't made the pM by MG.
ReplyDeleteHow an you ignore Blue Sar Raj Mohan? Do you mean to say that Raji Gandhi and his gundas during 84 riots tried to exploit the immaturity of Indiaans. Did 'Modi' ever gave any provocative statements? Why Rajiv Gandhi's name was not included alongwith Sajjan and Tytler for 84 for the investigation of Anti-Sikh genocide?
You people continously talk about Guj riots buu why you all conveniently ignore the point that before Guj Riots Godhra happened where 57 inncent karsevaks weer mercilessly burnt alive in Sabarmati Express on 27th Feb 2002. So these riots were just reactions. No goverment could have done much in that case. In any case you can't have different yardstiks for Narndra Modi and Rajiv Gandhi.
Babri Demolition I just want to say the matter is already subjudice in Rae Bareiley Court so you should not come to any conclusion. And even if are in such a hurry why ouldn't Congress lodge a single FIR against Mr.Advani, Dr.Josi and others even after Liberahon ommission deliverred its report. Is calling a ban on Cow salughter, appealing people to sing Vande Matram together, asking to revoke article 370 in J&K, asking the government to stop minority appeasement are the reasons to call BJP a fundamentalist party. Or you hyave some more valid reasons to say so? I hav no interests in viewing the maps issued by China our policy against Cina is very weak and te world knows that. And i didn't get answer from you why Congress didn't react over question marks raised by China on PM's visit to Arunachal. You mean to say India should forget POK i differ with you completely Kashmir runs in our blood we have every right to get back our lost territory. Regarding Guj eletions I think people of Guj ave given you an answer with the Panchayat Results where 100 Muslim Candidates of BJP have won. And finally I couldn't stop laughing on your 8 TH point
really nice my frnz Aman.
ReplyDeleteThe requirement of the situation is really great which allowed Mr Godshe to kill The Mahatma.
1)Pakistan was not financially balanced at par with India at the time f Independence.they were always second rated from the time f Independence.
2)M nt assuming bt its te fact tht Hindus were nt wanting to b ruled under Jinnah.n how can u assume tht Nehru had serious lust for the Prime ministership.
3No,Narendra Modi havnt given any provocative statement.I have given it na!!!n for the attack at kar sevaks at godhra,nobody is clear who the miscreants are-hindus or muslims...or the people of any organisation..
4)I hv given te reason 4 calling BJP a fundamentalist party?I havnt come at any conclusion for Babri Demolition.n te FIR had already been lodged against Advani,Murli Manohar Joshi,Uma Bharti,Kalyan singh etc..etc..
U can definitely understand the agendas of BJP are not going to fulfill in the so-called socialist present world.n nt definitely in India where 200million people are still Muslims.
5)thrs no point of laughing at te 8th point.bt to ponder at it n find the reasonable solutions.
1.) Who are we to take care of financial needs of Pakistan? We gave them help and we got a war as return as a return gift from them. :P
ReplyDelete2.) Pt. Nehru was having serious lust for power. Any politician would have sacrificed his PM's post if he knew that his competitor is going to die in sometimes because he was suffering from cancer and this would have thuse prevented the partition.
3.) Oh then who attacked on kar sevaks? I am sure after sometime you will come with a great analysis that 26/11 was done by RSS people. And you conveniently skipped to reply on Rajiv Gandhi's statement after his mother's assisination
4.) I think you didn't go through my posts thoroughly. My question why was no FIR lodged by the Union Home Ministry after the Liberrahon Commission Report was deliverred.
5.) That is why NDA Ruled state govts are coverring more than 60% population of the country.
6.) I am surprised to read your comparison of Hindutva with Jehad from an educated person like you. Ask any learned to explain you the meaning of Hindutva rather than reading the Congress manifesto.
7.:) The same so called financially and socially backward so called minority class has got atleast one member of their family on an average settled in Arab/ Gulf Countries who send Dinars and Darhams in India. So why crib about their backwardness?
Hellos
ReplyDeleteTo my friend Aman...
1)we wont gave them help.It is their right.The country is actually divided on the consent of both sides n te help is particularly Given by India 2 pakistan.It is the compromise on both sides on te instructions of Lord Mountbatten.
2)partition happened later n first the name"pakistan"came in the mind of Jinnah.moreover,having the cancer is nt a very good reason 4 becoming the PM f any country.
3)how can u come at te reasonable conclusion tht I'll say in future"26/11 is done by RSS???U cant predict anybody decisions.n my decisions are based on facts.The Godhra case is nt validated tht te attacks are done by muslims.If u hv any source,u can obviously provide me 1????
4)n Rajiv Gandhi statement will make him any terrorist or what???I think u hv definitely 4gotten the statements of Advani,Vajpayee,Kalyan singh,Uma bharti etc..etc..etc...
5)for ur 5th point,do u think is it right from the xample point of view???so what???the britishers had ruled our country 4 300years..so they r more favouratable than the BJP or Congress.
6)an educated person definitely cannot distinguish b/w Hindutva n Jehad.nt a single layman in India have understood the meaning of Hindutva..the BJP is showing the people of India "an absolute Mirage"-a country free of muslims,christians etc..etc.which is nt possible in Today's world...
7)If u definitely like the facts n figures,thn 4 te seventh point U can look at the report of "Sacchar Committee".and the no.of muslim graduates as compared to their population.
Good Bye....Tk Cr..........